Porch Herald

World edition

Public affairs

Canada’s grocery-property deal leaves old restrictions needing removal

Empire must respond to eligible removal requests within set deadlines, but the agreement does not eliminate every grocery-store lease restriction.

Businesses seeking a grocery site in Canada can still encounter old Empire restrictions in property records or leases, even where the company is no longer allowed to enforce them. A binding agreement provides a process to clear them.

The September consent agreement covers Empire, the parent of Sobeys, Safeway, Farm Boy and other grocery banners. It limits land-title restrictions that bind later owners, as well as certain lease clauses protecting existing stores from competitors.

The Competition Bureau says those controls can prevent new stores or restrict the products another retailer sells. Empire disputes the regulator’s conclusions and admitted no wrongdoing. Registration of the agreement was not a tribunal finding on those disputed claims.

A request starts the removal clock

Landlords, tenants, prospective tenants, purchasers, developers and others with a business interest in the affected property can request a waiver, title discharge, lease amendment or other removal covered by the agreement.

Empire must acknowledge the request within five business days. If it falls within the agreement, the company must take the necessary steps to remove the restriction within 20 business days, taking the requester’s commercial timetable into account. A refusal on grounds that the request is outside its commitments must give written reasons within the same 20-day period.

Empire publishes a property-control contact on its website. Clearing a restriction addresses that barrier; it does not establish that a new store has opened or that grocery prices have fallen.

Different restrictions have different limits

Empire cannot enforce existing grocery-related restrictive covenants or create new ones. It also cannot use covered lease restrictions to exclude specialty food retailers such as bakeries and butchers, or use radius clauses to restrict grocery sales on neighboring properties outside the development.

The ban on enforcing existing full-grocery lease exclusivity applies to 19 areas named in Schedule A. It is not a nationwide cancellation of every grocery exclusivity clause. The agreement defines those areas using census boundaries, rather than simply applying each municipality’s name to all surrounding property.

  • Alberta: Bonnyville.
  • New Brunswick: Grand Bay-Westfield.
  • Newfoundland and Labrador: Bishop’s Falls.
  • Nova Scotia: New Glasgow, New Ross, Pictou, Coldbrook and Truro.
  • Ontario: Paris and Thornbury.
  • Quebec: Cadillac, Lac Brome, Grenville, Repentigny, Victoriaville, Terrebonne, Contrecoeur, Saint-Hippolyte and Paspébiac.

Other grocers remain under review

The bureau said its investigations of other grocers’ property controls continue. Empire says such controls can support investment and development when used appropriately; its public policy also commits to limiting the geography, product coverage and duration of future grocery lease restrictions.

Sources