Porch Herald

World edition

Consumer

A refund announcement can mean cash, account credit or a claim

Three Australian consumer cases show why the payment method and required customer action matter as much as the headline penalty.

A company’s promise to refund customers does not always mean money will automatically return to their bank accounts. Australian consumer cases announced this year use different routes: automatic credits, requested refunds and claims from customers who never complained.

The difference affects whether a customer must respond, supply details through an official channel or choose money over credit on an account. Three cases illustrate how those mechanisms work.

Origin: an automatic credit or a requested refund

In July, the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission said some Origin Energy customers on its Ongoing Saver electricity plan had paid more than they would have on the Basic plan, despite representations that Ongoing Saver would remain cheaper.

The announced remedy gave current affected customers a choice: request a refund or receive an automatic account credit. Former customers would be contacted about a refund. Origin did not admit breaching consumer law; the regulator resolved the matter administratively after remediation and compliance commitments.

eDreams: former subscribers needed a different route

The ACCC’s June announcement concerned eligible eDreams Prime customers charged membership fees during an advertised free trial. Current eligible subscribers were to receive a refund or credit to an existing account.

For people no longer subscribed, eDreams committed to emailing a secure form on its website so they could provide refund details. The distinction was whether an account remained available to receive the remedy—not simply whether the customer had once paid a fee.

JustAnswer: an earlier complaint was not the only route

A July court order required refunds for Australian customers misled about the cost of JustAnswer’s service between November 2022 and August 2025. Some had been offered a AU$2 entry price but signed up for a continuing monthly subscription.

The company was to contact affected prior complainants who had not received full refunds. The ACCC also said consumers who had not previously complained could contact JustAnswer if they had been unaware of the continuing fees.

Remedy terms determine the next step

These cases describe the remedies announced in June and July, rather than a tally of completed payments. Their common lesson is to check the eligible group, payment method and official instructions separately.

Ordinary consumer-guarantee refunds have their own rules. The ACCC says a refund for a product with a major problem should use the original payment method unless the business and consumer agree otherwise. A case offering account credit does not replace that general rule.

Sources